Kwikset Premis vs Schlage vs August Electronic Locks – Buy the Best Lock for Your Home

When you’re out of town and need to let your dog sitter into your house, how do you do it? Telling them your garage code or leaving a key under the doormat isn’t very secure. New smart door locks are great for assigning unique codes to see who is coming and going. We are going to compare a few of the top smart door locks: Kwikset Premis vs Schlage vs August.

Kwikset Premis vs Schlage vs August

Affiliate Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links, which earn us a commission from Amazon at no cost to you.

Kwikset Premis vs Schlage vs August


Security

All devices have powerful encryption thanks to their HomeKit compatibility.

Kwikset Premis

SecureScreen requires 2 random numbers so that fingerprints do not give away the entry code

Optional security features like an alarm for incorrect codes and auto-lock

 BHMA/ANSI Grade 2 Certified (second best rating)

Schlage

Grade 1 Certified (highest residential rating available)

Built-in alarm senses attacks on the door

Codes can be up to 8 digits

August

Optional security feature for autolocking

Not certified. Since it works with your existing deadbolt, part of your security will depend on the quality of your deadbolt

Winner: Schlage

schlage connect

With Grade 1 Certification, Schlage Connect is the most secure lock of these three. Its additional security features make it the most trustworthy, although Kwikset Premis is a close 2nd place with its SecureScreen technology.


Keypad

Kwikset Premis

Keypad included on the deadbolt

Schlage

Keypad included on the deadbolt

August

An added keypad and can be purchased

Adding a keypad makes it more expensive

 

Winner: Schlage & Kwikset Premis

 schlage connect

Schlage and Kwikset both have built-in keypads which make it really convenient to enter without a smartphone. Being locked out without your phone can be a real pain. Having a keypad always there can remove a lot of the headaches of a smart lock. Many August owners have the auto lock feature turned on, making it easy to get locked out because they stepped outside without their phone for too long. Whoops. Keypads are nice for avoiding this annoying mistake.


Remote Access

All three locks allow you to create virtual keys for guest entry.

Kwikset Premis

 Remote access for HomeKit users

Create and manage up to 30 customizable user codes for family and friends

 Apple device and Apple TV (4th gen or later) needed for remote access to work

If you don’t have Apple products and have SmartThings or Wink checkout the Kwikset 916 Z-Wave.

Schlage

Uses Z-wave to connect remotely using Schlage Connect

Email access codes to guests using the app

Can’t have both Z-Wave and HomeKit compatible in the same device.

If you have an Apple TV 3 gen or above use the HomeKit compatible Schlage Sense

August

 Can be controlled remotely using August Connect

 Also compatible with HomeKit and can be controlled remotely with Apple TV 3 gen or above

August Connect is another thing to buy for it to work remotely

 

Winner: Tie

August Smart Lockschlage connect

This was a close match because each works remotely but has a few drawbacks. August isn’t tied to a specific platform but the August Connect is extra money. The Schlage and Kwikset can both connect to your existing smart home system but limit the options depending on which device you go with.


Compatibility

All three devices have HomeKit compatibility, along with the following features.

Kwikset Premis

 Works with iOS

No IFTTT compatibility

No Android compatibility

Schlage

Works on both iOS and Android

Works with SmartThings and Wink

No IFTTT compatibility

August

Works on both iOS and Android

Works with Amazon Alexa, Nest thermsotat and camera, XFINITY Home, Yonomi app, and Honeywell

Compatible with hubs including Wink hub and Logitech Harmony; August Connect WiFi bridge is required

Uses IFTTT and has its own channel

Winner: August

August Smart Lock

August continues adding more compatibility with other smart home devices than their competitors. IFTTT makes it possible for August to turn on your lights when you get home or turn off your GE oven when you leave. Schlage is compatible with multiple hubs, but they try to push the Nexia subscription which is slightly annoying.


Hardware

Kwikset Premis

 Adjustable backset to fit most doors for installation

Touchscreen keypad lights up when you place your hand in front of it

Schlage

 Very durable

 Easy to install

Low power indicator

August

 High build quality

Uses existing lock for easiest installation

 Very easy to install

Low power indicator

Winner: August

August Smart Lock

August still uses your existing deadbolt to open and close. It installs inside your home, with the outside of your home appearing like a standard door lock. This makes it very easy to install the August. Schlage and Kwikset Premis are also easy to install, but August still works with your existing physical keys. August also has its own doorbell cam which makes it easy to integrate a smart doorbell.


Overall Winner

 

And the winner of Kwikset vs Schlage vs August electronic locks is…

 

schlage connect

Schlage!

Schlage’s ultra security features, keypad, and easy remote access options make it the overall winner. Its strong Amazon reviews are promising and most customers seem to be happy with it. This was a close match because August is also a very high-quality door lock and very compatible with other devices.

Well, there you have it, the winner of Kwikset Premis vs Schlage vs August. Let us know in the comments below if there is anything we missed or any insights on these door locks.

  • August also supported by Logitech Harmony Hub, Wink Hub and Yonomi

    • Very true, thanks for noting that. We edited to add these devices’ compatibility with August. Thank you!

  • Bassem Rawas

    You’re kind of talking about Schlage Sense and Schlage Connect as 1 product, when they are 2 separate products, kind of biasing the article by lumping in only the pros of both combined.

    • Thanks for bringing that up. We have updated the comparison to just use the Schlage Connect.

Smart Home Solver Twitter Smart Home Solver Pinterest Smart Home Solver Facebook Smart Home Solver Flipboard share